Skip to main content

NAEP Technical Documentation2016 Summary Comparison Tables

The tables below summarize the percentage differences across item-response categories for the 2016 NAEP assessments. For each subject's instrument, the presented statistics include the difference in item response-category percentages across all the items in a group. In some circumstances, an item may have more than one response option or prompt. The percentages presented include the minimum, maximum, average, and median difference, all of which are expressed based upon the absolute value of the difference at the item-response level.

Summary of quality control error analysis for data processing of cognitive blocks in student booklets, by grade and assessment: 2016
AssessmentGradeNumber of response options/prompts
Average number of respondents in Contractor 2 databaseAverage difference in number of respondents between Contractor 2 database and Contractor 1 scored dataDifference in percentage at the response-category level
MinimumMaximumAverageMedian
Music81092,1144#0.350.030.01
Visual arts8442,1704#0.190.030.01
# Rounds to zero.
NOTE: Average difference in number of respondents is the average, across all response options, of the difference in the number of respondents for each response option in Contractor 1's file and the number in Contractor 2's file. In 2016, grades 4 and 12 were not assessed.
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2016 Assessment.
Summary of quality control error analysis for data processing of student survey questionnaires, by grade and assessment: 2016
AssessmentGradeNumber of response options/prompts
Average number of respondents in Contractor 2 databaseAverage difference in number of respondents between Contractor 2 database and Contractor 1 scored dataDifference in percentage at the response-category level
MinimumMaximumAverageMedian
Core (music)830
4,343180.010.180.110.11
Music8364,34318#0.250.040.11
Core (visual arts)830
4,41919#0.310.030.09
Visual arts8354,419190.020.200.110.10
# Rounds to zero.
NOTE: Average difference in number of respondents is the average, across all response options, of the difference in the number of respondents for each response option in Contractor 1's file and the number in Contractor 2's file. In 2016, grades 4 and 12 were not assessed.
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2016 Assessment.
Summary of quality control error analysis for data processing of school questionnaires, by grade and assessment: 2016
AssessmentGradeNumber of response options/prompts
Average number of respondents in Contractor 2 databaseAverage difference in number of respondents between Contractor 2 database and Contractor 1 scored dataDifference in percentage at the response-category level
MinimumMaximumAverageMedian
Music and visual arts
8124272#####
# Rounds to zero.
NOTE: Average difference in number of respondents is the average, across all response options, of the difference in the number of respondents for each response option in Contractor 1's file and the number in Contractor 2's file. In 2016, grades 4 and 12 were not assessed.
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2016 Assessment.



Last updated 13 February 2022 (SK)